717-249-3223 | 511 East Louther Street, Carlisle, Pennsylvania

Butcher Shop & Deli

Welcome to Wenger’s Old Fashion Butcher Shop & Deli. We have more than 30 years experience in growing and presenting some of the finest fresh meats and meal selections in the area. We are one of the few remaining butcher shops that offer beef and pork “on the rail” grown and delivered from local farmers.

We also offer a large variety of our own smoked meats, cheeses and freshly made salads that are unmatched in quality and pricing. In recent years we have greatly expanded our selection of prepared foods, and our faithful lunch crowd is always being exposed to some new and exciting sampler. Take a tour of our delights on this website. Then, come on in and help us help you create a healthy, balanced meal for your family.

• Fresh Meat (cut to your liking)
• Smoked Meat (Bolognas, Sausages, Snack Sticks)
• Fresh Seafood
• Scallops & Oysters
• Rotisserie Chickens
• Meat Bundles

• Hot & Cold Sandwiches
• Fresh Salad Bar
• Store-Made Deli Salads
• Fresh Nuts & Nibbles
• Holiday & Gift Ideas

PDF Icon Deli Menu

Local Products

Wenger Meats & Ice is proud to sell many local products including the following:

• Apple Valley Creamery milk
• Kay & Ray’s chips
• Kutztown soda
• Jake & Amos products
• Utz chips

Deli Menu

Hot Buffet & Soup

Wenger Meats & Ice offers a daily hot bar with soup. Check here for today’s selections.
https://wengermeats.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/01/01.21.pdf”>PDF Icon Hot Buffet & Soup

Bundled Meats

PDF Icon Bundled Meats Menu


PDF Icon Catering Menu

Catering costs listed below are for food only. Costs do not include decoration, arrangements for leasing banquet halls, availability of kitchen facilities, tables, chairs and coverings. We would be happy to arrange this for you at your request. Fees will be assessed on equipment that is lost, stolen or damaged.

Prices are determined based on a 100-person minimum. We will make price adjustments for less than 100. Minimum “on site” catering is $17.50 per person. Wenger Meats & Ice requires 25 percent down to confirm your order, and the balance is due within 7 days of completion.

Please contact us for more information or to get a quote.

Cold Buffet Menu

Starting at 9.50 per person for 100 or more
Includes the following:

Sliced Baked Ham, Turkey & Roast Beef Trays
Sliced Cheese Trays
Potato or Macaroni Salad
Sandwich Rolls
Iced Tea or Punch

Also available (at extra cost)

Lettuce, Tomatoes & Condiments Fresh Vegetable Trays Fresh Fruit Trays Fresh Fruit Salad

Potato Chips Cake, Cookies or Brownies Nuts & Mints Coffee


Starting at 12.00 per person for 25 or more
Your choice of Sandwich Platter, Side Salad and Dessert. Served with Potato Chips.
Beverages available (extra cost)

Sandwich Platters

Subs (Ham, Turkey, Roast Beef, Italian)
Wraps (Ham, Turkey, Roast Beef, Italian)
Deli Sandwiches (Ham, Turkey, Roast Beef, Italian)
Deli Sandwiches (Chicken Salad, Ham Salad & Tuna Salad)
Kaiser Sandwiches (Ham, Turkey, Roast Beef)


Side Salads

    • Potato Salad
    • Macaroni Salad
    • Broccoli Cauliflower Salad
    • Cole Slaw
      • Pasta Salad
      • Fresh Fruit Salad
      • Fresh Fruit Tray
      • Fresh Vegetable Tray



  • Assorted Cookies
  • Fresh Fruit Tray
  • Brownies
  • Pie Slices
  • Chicken Corn
  • Vegetable Beef
  • Ham & Bean
  • Chili
  • Wild Rice Chicken Mushroom
  • Tomato Basil
  • Seafood Chowder
  • White Chicken Chili



(Prices vary with selection)


  • Fresh Fruit Tray
  • Assorted Cheeses & Crackers
  • Cubed Meat & Cheese Tray
  • Fresh Vegetable Tray w/ Dip
  • Spinach Dip in Bread Bowl
  • Wrap Sandwich Spirals
  • Finger Sandwiches
  • Fresh Bruschetta
  • Shrimp Cocktail
  • Deviled Eggs
  • Pickled Eggs
  • Chocolate Covered Strawberries

  • Sweet & Sour Meatballs
  • Sweet & Sour Cocktail Wieners
  • Mini Quiches
  • Wings
  • BBQ Smoked Sausage Bites
  • Mini Chicken Cordon Bleu
  • Pineapple & Chicken Mini Kabobs
  • Shrimp Kabobs
  • Bacon Wrapped Scallops
  • Crab Stuffed Mushrooms

Hot Buffet Menu

Your choice of 2 Entrees, 1 Potato/Pasta, 1 Salad and 1 Vegetable, Dinner Rolls & Butter.
Also includes Dessert, Coffee & Tea and your choice of Iced Tea, Lemonade or Punch
Starting at 19.50 per person for 100 or more


Roast Beef
Baked Ham w/ Pineapple Glaze
Roast Turkey
Glazed Ham Balls w/ Pineapple
Roast Pork Loin w/ Stuffing
Italian Stuffed Pork Loin
Marinated Pork Loin
Steamship Round of Beef
Beef Rollups
Stuffed Chicken Breast
Chicken Marsala
Chicken Cordon Bleu
Stuffed Shells w/ Meatballs
Pasta w/ Fresh Vegetables
Steak Primavera
Turkey or Chicken Broccoli Alfredo


Wenger’s Specialty Entree

  • Grilled Salmon w/ Dill
  • Seafood Alfredo
  • Beef Medallions w/ Red Wine Sauce

  • Prime Rib
  • Crab Imperial
  • Crab Stuffed Flounder

Potato / Pasta

  • Scalloped Potatoes
  • Mashed Potatoes w/ Gravy
  • Macaroni & Cheese
  • Roasted Red Skin Potatoes
  • Sweet Potato Casserole
  • Gourmet Potato Casserole
  • Bread Stuffing
  • Rice Pilaf


  • Fresh Fruit Salad
  • Caesar Salad
  • Broccoli Cauliflower Salad
  • Tossed Salad


  • Buttered Corn
  • Green Beans Amandine
  • Broccoli Casserole
  • Key West Blend
  • Honey Glazed Carrots
  • Normandy Blend
  • Riviera Blend


  • Brownies
  • Cake
  • Cookies (chocolate chip, oatmeal raisin, macadamia nut…)
  • Pies (apple, cherry, peach, pumpkin, apple caramel nut…)
  • Cheesecake w/ cherry or blueberry toppings


Starting at 14.00 for 25 or more
Your choice of 1 entrée, 1 Potato/Pasta, 1 Hot Vegetable OR 1 Salad and Dessert.
Includes Roll & Butter
Assorted Beverages available (extra cost)



Picnic Menu

Your choice of 1 Entree, 1 Side and 2 Salads.
Also includes Potato Chips and Assorted Cookies
Beverages available. (extra cost)
Starting at 14.50 for 100 persons or more

PIG ROASTS are our specialty!

Entrees From the Grill

  • Hamburgers & Hot Dogs*
  • BBQ Chicken
  • BBQ Ribs
  • Grilled Chicken Breasts
  • Sausage Grillers*
Other Entrees

  • Pulled Pork BBQ*
  • Pulled Chicken BBQ*
  • BBQ Beef Brisket*
  • Wings
  • (Naked or choose from 5 other flavors)
*Rolls & Condiments provided for the above selections
Pig Roasts, Grilled Steaks, Seafood also available

Breakfast Menu

for 25 persons or more
Continental Breakfast – starting at 6.00 per person
Coffee, Assorted Pastries, Fresh Fruit Tray or Salad

Hot Breakfast

Continental Breakfast plus 1 item below – starting at 8.00
Continental Breakfast plus 2 items below – starting at 10.00
Continental Breakfast plus 3 items below – starting at 12.00

Breakfast Casserole
Creamed Chipped Beef over Biscuits
Ham, Bacon or Sausage (Choice of One)
Baked Oatmeal
Baked French Toast
Quiche (Choose one):
Bacon Tomato Swiss or Farmers’ or
Lorraine or Florentine



About Our Catering

Standard Drop-off Catering Service includes:
Set-up at your location
Disposable table coverings and place settings
Standard catering equipment
All catering equipment must be cleaned and returned

Full Service Catering includes:
Set-up at your location
Disposable table coverings & place settings
Creative Presentation
Wait staff

Additional Services Available
China & Glassware
Other Rental Equipment

There are fees associated with all these options depending on travel
distance, amount of service required, etc..


Wengers also offers…
Party Trays
Bag Lunches
Fundraiser Subs & Sandwiches
Custom Cut Meats
Custom Wild Game Processing
Our Own Smoked Sausages, Hams, Bolognas & Snack Sticks
And a Retail Store with a Full Service Deli and Kitchen

Party Trays

PDF Icon Party Trays


Sliced Meat & Cheese Tray

Choice of 3 Deli Meats & 3 Cheeses. Includes mayonnaise & mustard.

  • 18” tray (serves 18-25)
  • 16” tray (serves 15-18)
  • 12” tray (serves 8-12)
  • $69.99
  • $59.99
  • $45.99


Choice of 4 Deli Meats & 3 Cheeses. Includes a mustard dipping sauce.

  • 18” tray (serves 18-25)
  • 16” tray (serves 15-18)
  • 12” tray (serves 8-12)
  • $69.99
  • $59.99
  • $45.99


Choice of up to 6 Cheeses. Includes a mustard dipping sauce.

  • 18” tray (serves 18-25)
  • 16” tray (serves 15-18)
  • 12” tray (serves 8-12)
  • $59.99
  • $49.99
  • $35.99

Party Sub

Ham, Italian, Roast Beef, Turkey or the combination of two.

  • Six-Foot
  • Three-Foot
  • $69.99
  • $49.99

Pastry Tray

A variety of pastries.

  • 18” tray (serves 25-30)
  • 16” tray (serves 15-20)
  • 12” tray (serves 10-15)
  • $59.95
  • $39.95
  • $29.95

Cookie Tray

Includes a variety of cookies such as Chocolate Chip, Oatmeal Raisin, Snickerdoodle,
White Chocolate Macadamia Nut, M&M, Reeses Peanut Butter Cup

  • 18” tray (75 cookies)
  • 16” tray (50 cookies)
  • 12” tray (25 cookies)
  • $49.95
  • $34.95
  • $19.95

Vegetable Tray

Includes: carrots, celery, cucumbers, sweet bell peppers, broccoli, cauliflower, cherry
tomatoes and a creamy ranch dip

  • 18” tray (serves 18-25)
  • 16” tray (serves 15-18)
  • 12” tray (serves 8-12)
  • $36.99
  • $26.99
  • $19.99

Fresh Fruit Tray

Includes: cantaloupe, grapes, honey dew, pineapple, strawberries, watermelon and a
light fruit dip

  • 18” tray (serves 18-25)
  • 16” tray (serves 15-18)
  • 12” tray (serves 8-12)
  • $49.99
  • $39.99
  • $29.99

LTO Tray

Freshly sliced lettuce, tomatoes & onions.

  • 18” tray (serves 36-50)
  • 16” tray (serves 30-36)
  • 12” tray (serves 16-24)
  • $25.99
  • $19.99
  • $14.99

Chicken Wing Tray

Prepared Spicy hot or mild BBQ. Served with Ranch or Bleu Cheese Dressing

  • 16” tray (serves 15-18)
  • 12” tray (serves 8-12)
  • $39.99
  • $29.99

Steamed Shrimp

  • 16-20 ct
  • 21-25 ct
  • $14.95 lb
  • $12.95 lb
Add $2 per lb to peel
Add $2 per lb to devein
Add $10.00 to display on tray





Apple, Apple Caramel Nut, Blueberry, Cherry, Lemon Sponge,
Peach, Pecan, Pumpkin, Shoo-fly…

  • 10″ pie
  • $11.99


PDF Icon Fundraising

Wenger Meats & Ice is famous for making top quality hoagies and sandwiches for fundraising events. All our hoagies are made from the freshest Terranetti’s rolls and the finest quality meat and cheeses. These are NOT your typical fundraising sandwiches. They are loaded with meat and made to ensure that your faithful supporters will receive real value for their contributions.

Share This